Metro North Graveyard, 2002

Published on: August 16th, 2015 Written by:


In 2002 we stopped by Metro North’s graveyard to poke around the oddball collection of junk commuter train equipment stored and awaiting a date with either the scrappers torch or, less likely, resale and restoration. This collection of locomotives and rail cars represented some of the best and worst in terms of reliability & design.

In terms of design, the FL9’s were classic ‘cab’ units. They were built to run off both a standard diesel engine or 3rd rail power, for operation into Grand Central Terminal. They were originally built in the 1960s for the New Haven Railroad, which was later absorbed into the doomed Penn Central railroad (which went bankrupt), then Conrail, and eventually the MTA.

During the Penn Central years, locomotive maintenance was always a problem. There were never enough spare parts to go around: “My first working assignment was FL9s, and considering the way they were maintained under Penn Central it is a miracle they were able to operate at all. I recall many of them were missing some of the third rail pickup shoes as the railroad was constantly out of stock and could not afford to buy them. You could look back in the engine room when running on third rail and watch the light flashes as electrical equipment dropped out and picked up under full load. This kind of abuse of course ultimately cost the railroad much more in equipment repair expenses than the cost of putting on a full set of shoes, but that could all be conveniently blamed on EMD to hide the reason it was really happening. ” – P Cook. (Comment found here, accessed 8/2015).

Despite the abuse, the majority of FL9 locomotives saw regular usage into the early 2000s, and the last were ‘retired’ from Metro North in 2009.


3 of the FL9s present (and seen in these photos) wrapped up their careers on the Long Island Railroad, as part of the 1990s experimental use of bi-level cars on diesel hauled trains to the far reaches of the island. This successful experiment resulted in the LIRR replacing its entire diesel haul fleet of passenger cars with bi-level cars and newer locomotives. While on the LIRR, they were numbed 300, 301 and 302. 300 and 302 were the most reliable, while 301 was used as a back up. Of note – 301 was originally New Haven #5000 – one of the first FL9s constructed (in 1957). As you can see in these photos, 301 was in the worst shape of the lot, and was ultimately cut up for scrap metal along with the other former LIRR engines.
M checking out the engine lube..

FL9 Interior

2 Lines of FL9s and SPVs

Nose of FL9 2010.


Metro North 2010 was also in this line of dead engines – it however survived and is on the Cooperstown & Charlotte Valley Railroad in upstate NY. Currently it’s not in use, though word is that they have a second FL9 (2028) currently being repaired. Even if 2010 never runs again, some of its parts will likely keep the other running for years to come.

The M1 cars were produced in the hundreds. They’re far less unique than anything else found in this junk collection, but they were notable for when they were placed in service in the 1970s, they were some of the first Metro North cars to have air conditioning.

I’m not quite sure why this single M1 car was at the graveyard, so if you have any info, be sure to comment. Unfortunately I have no idea what the car number was. (It’s also possible that this was an M3 car, since they look so similar…)

The SPVs, or ‘seldom powered vehicles’ were a failed replacement for the far more reliable Budd RDC cars. These self-powered passenger cars were purchased by the MTA for use on shuttle trains from Poughkeepsie to the electrified rail at Croton (where passengers would switch to a train of M1A or M3 cars). These cars were highly unreliable, and often had to be pulled by diesel locomotives.



Together, this collection of battered passenger cars and locomotives hauled commuters from point A to point B in the best and worst of times. The technology behind them has been built upon in the current generation of commuter rail equipment. For example, the 1990s LIRR bi-level test (powered by the FL9s) resulted in a larger purchase of diesel/electric locomotives and bilevel cars in the late 1990s – nearly all of which are still in use today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • About The Author

    Bad Guy Joe

    Bad Guy Joe
    Bad Guy Joe knows more about the NYC underground than anyone else on or below the surface of this planet. He has spent nearly 30 years sneaking into NYC's more forbidden locations. When not underground, he's probably bitching about politicians or building something digital. 
  • Recent Comments

  • Check out our Twitter feed

  • Social

  • Instagram Feed

  • Featured Press