The demolished Astoria Presbyterian Church

Published on: December 11th, 2017 | Last updated: December 10, 2017 | Written by: Bad Guy Joe

---

The Astoria Presbyterian church was located on 33rd street, near 31st avenue. It was demolished in 2010.

History

This church was built in 1922, and opened with a large ceremony. According to the long defunct Long Island City Star Journal “The weather was ideal as more than 1,000 members and friends of the church attended the event. All around the foundations of the new church were the foundation of new apartment houses and homes. Soon hundreds of families would be moving in.”. Astoria, at the time, was still a very new neighborhood. Apartment buildings and homes were being constructed and the nearby Astoria elevated subway (today’s N and W lines) had just opened.

The church peeked in attendance around the 1950s, and settled into a long decline in the decades after. Finally, in the late 2000s, a decision needed to be made. With less than 50 congregants left, the church was having trouble paying the bills and maintaining its various buildings (the church itself, a schoolhouse, garage and parsonage) and paying the utility bills. Estimates for maintenance and repairs were in the millions, though this number was hotly disputed. The decision to sell the property rather than try to save it divided the remaining congregation.

The building was ultimately sold to a community group that razed the buildings and replaced them with an elder care facility.

Adventure
During that sweet period between activity and demolition, me and Timmy swooped in for some photos, early one September Sunday morning. Ironically this would be the only time I entered this church, despite having grown up a few blocks away.

Right about the time we entered on a Sunday morning, during normal circumstances, this building would be filled with prayer. Instead, it was left without a prayer in the world, and in some ways, it was the prey: just another building for us to swoop into and use for decay-porn photo prizes.

Much had been removed from the buildings, while much had been left behind to await its one way ticket to a landfill. Amid the ruins we found a few trinkets worth saving. Included were the 48 star US flag that was at the front of the church, and a bible with the church’s name inscribed on the front. Later, the flag & bible were donated to the Greater Astoria Historical Society.

This beautiful stamp, showing the building’s exterior, remained with me though and will be a part of my personal collection for the foreseeable future.

Few traces of these buildings can be found today. One of the main artifacts to be preserved was one of the stained glass windows, which somehow made its way to the Brigham Young University Museum of Art – all the way out in Utah.

Over on Broadway, this sign remains high on a street lamp at the corner of 33rd and Broadway (so far as I know)

The Lost Time Capsule?
Going back to the original Star Journal article, there’s one more passage worth mentioning:
“John MacKenzie made and sealed the box inside the cornerstone. It was cut by A. Hill and donated by Samuel Jones. Inside this cornerstone they placed a Bible, copies of the Star, Herald, and Post, names and photographs of the pastor, elders and trustees, a church manual from 1845, a church directory, a program for the cornerstone ceremony, coins from one cent to $1, medallions worn at the celebration of the Queensboro Bridge opening, and a church history. “

It is unknown, and perhaps even unlikely, that this time capsule was recovered during demolition. If it was, the Greater Astoria Historical Society did not seem to know of it when I presented them with the bible and flag.

For a few more photos, check out Timmy’s Flickr album – these shots are of course amazeballs and so much better than my usual shtick.

Comments

NOTE: It sometimes takes a short while for comments to be approved - unfortunately there's a lot of spam comments that come in. I absolutely love when y'all share personal stories of friends relatives etc who worked in these places. It really helps capture what these places were like before they closed up shop.

If you're feeling salty, argumentative comments completely devoid of facts (supply links to support your argument) will not be published. Got a case to state? come with the details.

5 responses to “The demolished Astoria Presbyterian Church”

1. Mickey says:

   May 15, 2018 at 9:44 PM

   I was a Boy Scout wit troop 90 that met every Tuesday in the gym next door to the church Dr Williams was running things then 1952 until 1962 I was 10 then 20. Great values learned n lots of fun I’m now 75 h have black n white pictures of scouts. I couldn’t find troop 90 I guess it was dissolved any feedback would be appreciated

2. Holly Archer says:

   January 8, 2020 at 12:05 PM

   I went to the church, as a little child, in the 1950’s and remember the stained glass windows. I thougt they were just beautiful and I loved to stare at them. Too bad there was no way to preserve them….would anyone have any pictures of them?

3. Marion J Drage says:

   September 19, 2021 at 10:23 PM

   My grandfather was an elder in this church till his death in 1971. I was confirmed here in 1867. Dr. Williams was the pastor. After he retired a few years later a new pastor was hired. The church began to go down hill from there. The new pastor only cared about you filling your offering envelopes, not about you as a person. I was officially tossed out of the congregation for failure to give. I was a minor child. That action caused my mother and grandmother to leave. My grandfather died shortly after.
   So sad about that beautiful church. My friends and I were driving along 33rd street today, 9/19/2021 and I couldn’t find the church. I found the article on it being demolished. It broke my heart and ruined the rest of my day.

4. Bob D says:

   November 8, 2021 at 12:08 PM

   I was a member of pack 90 then troop 90 back in the early 1960’s. My mother sang in the choir and I in the Jr. choir, my mother grew up around the corner on 34th Street andI think she was married in the church not sure. I was looking for some info about the church to add to ancestry and sadly found this article and I still feel bad but have fond memories of the church. Enlisted in the Navy in 1971 and moved to Mass. and have never been back but hope to soon.

5. BobB says:

   December 9, 2022 at 4:03 PM

   Remember playing basketball in the late 1950’s on what is arguably one of the best church teams in the City’s history.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.